48HBC 2014, Review #1: Renegade Magic


Title: Renegade Magic (Kat, Incorrigible: Book 2) Author: Stephanie Burgis Publication: Atheneum Books for Young Readers; April 03, 2012 Hardcover: 331 pages

Five hours into the Challenge, I am happy to report that I’ve finished the first book that Moxie selected for me. Renegade Magic is the second book in Stephanie Burgis’ Kat, Incorrigible series; I thought (as did Moxie) that it might behoove me to start my reading off with a story I was already invested in. As I’m unused to a 7am wake-up time, I needed something to hoist me out of my morning grumpiness and immediately capture my attention. This — and coffee — did the trick. I knew we’d made the right decision when, not even 2 pages into the text, I encountered these lines: “‘ You do know, Kat,’ he whispered, ‘Stepmama will murder you for this if she finds out.’ He was yawning so hard that most people wouldn’t have been able to decipher his words, but I had long experience” (1). I nodded appreciatively. Yes, yawning. 7 a.m. It’s ungodly.
And I kept reading.

Burgis’ series is like a mind-blowingly amazing combination of Jane Austen & Harry Potter. It’s Regency manners and romance mixed with mischief and middle-grade magic. In the first novel, Kat and her two older sisters (Angeline and Elissa) discover the magical legacy that their mother left them upon her death. They defeat villains, meet heroic men, save heroic men and act as heroes themselves, and act in a generally unruly and uproarious manner (except for Elissa, who would never think of acting in such a way), defying the expectations of 1800’s English Society at every turn.

The second novel is much of the same, while managing to stay fresh and avoid becoming tedious. What I love most about this series (aside from the mix of two seemingly-disparate genres) is that Burgis flawlessly and subtly introduces the issues of freedom and slavery; individuality and conformity; prejudice; ignorance; and gender roles. This is most clear in Burgis’ treatment of “pacification,” which is what happens when the Guardians — a magical order entrusted with the task of protecting Society from nefarious magical forces — deems a witch to be too “willful,” i.e. averse to putting adherence to the Law above her personal code of ethics, morals, and desires. If a lady is deemed thus, she’s “pacified” — stripped of her powers entirely, a process which oftentimes damages the woman’s mind, leaving her an invalid. This is concurrent with what was done, historically, to women that Society deemed “willful.” They were placed in mental institutions and given shock treatments that would make them more “manageable” and “subservient,” as it was believed women should rightly be.

The books also show that feminism, romance, a belief in true love, and a desire to marry, aren’t necessarily at odds.

The series falls somewhere between Middle Grade and Young Adult, and it’s possible to read it without any of these subtexts and still enjoy it simply as a rollicking fantasy/adventure, but as an adult I’m happy I’m able to recognize them for what they are. The only tricky thing with recommending this book to its intended audience is that the romantic subplots (for Kat’s sisters, not for Kat) and the period affectation may be too much for most Middle Grade readers, while the protagonist’s age — Kat’s only twelve-years-old – may discourage Teens. But if you’re a Children’s-Lit-loving adult, you’re going to be totally blissed-out by the whole affair.

Rating: 4 out of 5 crumpets.
Quite decadent! (Yes, quite).

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to 48HBC 2014, Review #1: Renegade Magic

  1. This book sounds spectacular! Adding it to my to-read list now…

  2. Charlotte says:

    Oh yes, this is a good one! I enjoyed it much more than the first. and now you get to look forward to book 3! I’m so sad there probably aren’t going to be more books…I would have happily read on and on and on…

  3. I enjoyed those Stephanie Burgis books. That Kat is a keeper!

  4. I love these books, too! And she’s working on a fourth novella right now, per her blog.

  5. Pingback: 48HBC 2014: Finish Line | No Boys Allowed Reviews

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s